top of page

The Healing House - Your Environment, Your Science

BE-14

Four questions sit underneath everything we publish, and none of them has been settled in a British wall. This page sets out what the published research already shows, including findings that cut against our own position, the experiment that would answer each question, and what result would prove us wrong. A gap named in an article becomes an experiment here, and an experiment becomes a finding only when it has been run.

Your Environment, Your Science


Every article in this series ends at the edge of what is known. The Wall Is Sweating, BE-01, closes with honest admissions of what has not yet been measured. This pillar is where those admissions are turned into experiments.


The Healing House is not a marketing page. It is the research programme underneath everything else we publish. Its governing rule is simple. A gap named in a published article becomes an experiment specified here. An experiment becomes a finding only when it has been run. Nothing moves from this programme into a public claim without data.


One Piece of Housekeeping


Every source named on this page was read in the building of the programme. Where a finding is established, we say so and name it. Where a question is open, we say that too. Some of what we found cuts against our own earlier position, and we have reported it as plainly as the findings that support us.


This programme studies buildings. It makes no health claims, and nothing on this page is a treatment or a promise about anyone's wellbeing.


How the Programme Was Built


The evidence was gathered in three passes: published literature first, then our own research library, then published literature again to check whatever the library had surfaced.


The order matters. Our library contains both outside research and our own earlier writing. A search tool cannot tell the two apart, and well-written internal summaries can rank alongside the research they were drawn from, then be mistaken for independent support. Checking against outside literature before and after keeps that from happening. It is how we caught one figure, discussed below, that did not survive measurement.


Question One: Does Biofilm Keep British Brick Wetter for Longer?


Status: open. This is the load-bearing question.


We have withdrawn the claim that the biological film on a wall acts like a sponge, holding water against the brick. When we traced it, it rested on internal summary, not on measurement. The mechanism is plausible. It has simply not been shown on British brick and render, which is a different thing from being false.


What is established is more complicated than either side of the argument usually admits. Camuffo (1995) noted that no general formula links damage to how long a surface stays wet. Cutler (2013) found algal greening on Belfast sandstone largely unrelated to surface moisture. Prieto and colleagues (2021), working at Stirling Castle, found that moisture a few centimetres below the surface mattered more for colonisation than the surface itself.


And one finding cuts against us. Jang and colleagues (2021), working on British limestone at Kelmscott Manor and Chipping Norton, found that mosses may shield the stone beneath from light rainfall, and that removing them may disturb the moisture regime more than leaving them in place. Moss on limestone is not algae on fired brick, and shielding from light rain is not the same as drying after heavy rain, but the honest position is less certain than we once said.


The Experiment for Question One


Take paired cores from the same façade: one colonised, one cleaned with a deionised-water rinse rather than bleach, because bleach leaves salts behind that would confuse the result. Seal their sides, let them dry from one face only, and log their weight continuously.


If the colonised and cleaned cores dry at rates that cannot be told apart, the biological half of our argument reduces to appearance, and we will say so publicly.


Question Two: Does Internal Insulation Cause Frost Damage in British Walls?


Status: modelled thoroughly elsewhere, not measured in Britain.


Modelling studies agree that insulating a solid wall on the inside makes the outer brick colder and wetter in winter, which raises the modelled risk of freeze–thaw damage (Zhou and colleagues, 2017, Swiss climates; Sahyoun and colleagues, Canadian climates).


Two findings from that same literature narrow the claim. A warming climate can reduce freeze–thaw risk in some places and raise it in others (Zhou and colleagues, 2020). And the climate indices commonly used to rank the risk were found not to represent actual performance (Sahyoun and colleagues, 2021).


So the honest position is narrower than the modelling suggests. Internal insulation raises the modelled risk, the usual ways of ranking that risk have been shown to fail, and nobody has measured it in a British wall.


The Experiment for Question Two


Moisture and temperature probes at depth, with acoustic sensors to listen for cracking, on a north-west-facing solid wall through a full winter, before and after internal insulation.


Because sound fades quickly in masonry (Verstrynge and colleagues, 2020), a signal-loss survey has to come first, or the recordings cannot be interpreted. If a full winter records no cracking signals linked to frost at depth, the freeze–thaw case remains modelling without measurement.


Question Three: Do the Damp-Wall Correction Figures Still Hold?


Status: not yet checked against the original. Highest return for least effort.


UK guidance on calculating heat loss through walls tells the assessor to adjust the thermal conductivity of masonry for its moisture content, using values in CIBSE Guide A. Every heat-loss figure for a solid wall depends on those values.


The task is a reading exercise, not a laboratory one: obtain the guide, extract the moisture values and the data behind them, and compare them with modern measurements of historic brick. One reason to check is that Roels and colleagues (2023) found that, for historic brick, thermal conductivity does not follow density as neatly as older assumptions suggest.


Question Four: At What Depth Should Moisture Be Measured?


Status: partly answered.


Orr and colleagues (2019) compared microwave and radar moisture surveys on stone walls under simulated wind-driven rain. Microwave readings separated four distinct moisture regimes. Radar picked out water entering through mortar joints, which microwave missed. And the authors noted that there is still no agreed best practice for collecting and presenting this kind of data.


For lime-mortared solid walls, where joints are often the main moisture path, that matters. The experiment is a paired microwave and radar survey of the same British brick wall, before and after a measured spell of driving rain.


A Figure We Corrected


An internal summary in our library stated that mosses and biofilms hold up to 20 times their dry weight in water. Measured directly, the figure does not hold. Ursavaş and Edis (2025) found that four moss species held between 300% and 700% of their dry weight, three to seven times, reaching equilibrium within 10 to 20 minutes.


We use the measured range. A figure that fails a reviewer's first check costs more than it gains, and the measured range is striking enough on its own. The same study found that mosses differ in the minerals they release into water, a possible route for chemical attack on mortar that we had not considered.


The Order We Will Work In


  • First: read the damp-wall correction figures in the original guide. No fieldwork, no equipment.

  • Second: run the paired drying experiment, which tests the question that matters most.

  • Third: the paired microwave and radar survey, to make sure we measure at the right depth with the right tool.

  • Fourth: the winter freeze–thaw study, the most costly and the longest, which needs a cooperative building and a full winter.


How This Connects to the Rest of the Series


The public white paper that accompanies this series, Anthrotectonic Hylodynamics: Coupled Transport and the Biological Boundary Layer of the Building Envelope, sets out the full laboratory and field protocol behind these experiments, including how results will be reported when they are inconclusive.


Every result, whichever way it falls, will be recorded here first and then carried into the articles that depend on it.


Adversarial Triangulation and Falsifiability


A research programme that cannot fail is not a research programme. These are the results that would make us change what we say:


  • If colonised and cleaned cores dry at the same rate, the biological argument becomes cosmetic, and we retire it.

  • If a winter of monitoring records no cracking signals linked to frost at depth, the freeze–thaw case is modelling without measurement, and we say so.

  • If the damp-wall correction figures prove sound against modern data, our argument about heat-loss calculations narrows to a procedural point.

  • If the shielding effect Jang found on limestone also applies to biofilm on brick, then removal is the wrong default in some exposures, and our advice becomes conditional.


That last one is the one to watch. It is the only finding here that, if it holds, would change what we do on site, not just what we say.


The Open Invitation


This article is one pillar of fifteen.


We invite universities, building scientists, conservation bodies and owners of solid-walled buildings to take part in these experiments. A paired drying study needs two cores and a careful laboratory. A winter monitoring study needs one cooperative building. Either would move the evidence further than another article could.


Continue reading the series:



Your environment, your science. Measure it before you believe it.


Read the industry discussion paper


Thank you for reading.

bottom of page